Deferred Sales Trusts: Pros and Cons

Selling a high-value asset? A Deferred Sales Trust (DST) might help you manage capital gains taxes. Instead of paying taxes upfront, you defer them by spreading payments over time. Unlike 1031 exchanges, DSTs work for various assets - businesses, stocks, real estate, and more. However, they come with setup costs, compliance risks, and limited liquidity. Here's what you need to know:

• Key Benefits:
  • Defer taxes and manage payments over years.
  • Invest proceeds in diverse assets (not just real estate).
  • Useful for estate planning and wealth transfer.
• Challenges:
  • High setup fees ($5,000–$15,000+) and ongoing costs.
  • IRS compliance risks due to lack of explicit recognition.
  • Limited access to full sale proceeds upfront.

DSTs work best for large transactions where tax deferral outweighs costs. Professional guidance is essential to avoid compliance issues and maximize benefits.

Deferred Sales Trusts: Everything You Need To Know

What Are Deferred Sales Trusts

A Deferred Sales Trust (DST) is a type of irrevocable trust that acts as a middleman between you and the buyer of an asset. Instead of selling your asset - like a business, real estate, or securities - directly to the buyer, you transfer ownership to the DST. The trust then sells the asset and holds the proceeds. Rather than receiving a lump sum, you get installment payments over a set period. This approach not only simplifies the sale process but also offers notable tax advantages.

Thanks to the installment sale rules under IRC Section 453, you only pay capital gains taxes as you receive payments, rather than all at once. For example, if you sell an asset for $10 million through a DST and arrange to receive $1 million annually over ten years, you’ll pay capital gains tax on just $1 million each year. This can help you manage your tax burden more effectively.

How DSTs Work in Tax-Deferral Strategies

The key to a DST’s tax benefits lies in its ability to prevent "constructive receipt" of the sale proceeds. Since the funds remain under the trust’s control, your tax liability is deferred. During this deferral period, the trust can invest the proceeds in assets like stocks, bonds, or real estate, potentially growing the overall value while you wait for your scheduled payments.

DSTs are particularly useful for those exiting growth-stage companies. For instance, when a founder sells their stake in a startup or a private equity firm cashes out of an investment, the capital gains can be substantial. A DST allows sellers to stretch the tax payments over several years, which can help keep them in lower tax brackets and preserve more of their wealth for reinvestment or personal goals.

Flexibility Beyond Real Estate

One of the standout features of DSTs is their flexibility. Unlike 1031 exchanges, which are limited to real estate transactions, DSTs can be applied to nearly any type of appreciated asset. Whether you’re selling a business, stocks, bonds, or even intellectual property, a DST can work for you. This makes them especially appealing to entrepreneurs and investors with diverse portfolios who are looking for tax-deferral options beyond the constraints of traditional real estate-focused strategies.

Supporting Exit Planning and Managing Capital Gains

DSTs can play a critical role in exit planning, particularly for business owners who’ve built significant value in their companies. Instead of taking a lump-sum payout - and facing a hefty tax bill - DSTs allow for structured installment payments. This provides steady income over time and gives you breathing room to plan for long-term investments or estate transfers.

It’s worth noting, however, that DSTs aren’t explicitly recognized by the IRS. Instead, they rely on established provisions within the tax code. Because of this, it’s essential to structure and document the trust correctly to maintain its tax benefits and reduce the risk of audit complications. Proper legal and financial guidance is a must when setting up a DST.

Pros and Cons of Deferred Sales Trusts

Deferred Sales Trusts (DSTs) come with both perks and challenges, making it essential to weigh their suitability for your financial goals. Below, we break down the key benefits and drawbacks of DSTs.

Benefits of Deferred Sales Trusts

Tax Deferral and Management

One of the standout benefits of a DST is the ability to delay paying capital gains taxes on highly appreciated assets. Instead of facing a hefty tax bill upfront, taxes are paid gradually as you receive installment payments. For example, if you sell an asset worth $2,000,000, structuring the sale over several years can ease the tax burden while allowing the proceeds to grow in a tax-deferred environment ^[1].

Investment Flexibility

Unlike a 1031 exchange, which limits reinvestment to similar types of real estate, DSTs offer much broader investment options. Sale proceeds can be directed into a variety of assets, such as real estate, stocks, bonds, or even business interests. This flexibility also extends to the types of assets eligible for a DST, including businesses, intellectual property, and more ^[2].

Estate Planning Opportunities

DSTs also shine as estate planning tools. They allow wealth to be passed down to beneficiaries over time, potentially reducing estate taxes. For example, real estate holdings can be distributed through structured payments, aligning with your long-term estate planning goals ^[3].

Drawbacks of Deferred Sales Trusts

While DSTs offer attractive benefits, they come with notable downsides that require careful consideration.

High Setup and Management Costs

Setting up a DST can be complex and expensive. Legal and financial expertise is essential, with setup fees typically ranging from $5,000 to $15,000 or more. Additionally, ongoing trustee and management fees - often between 0.5% and 1.5% of assets annually - can add up, especially for smaller transactions where costs may outweigh the benefits ^[1].

IRS Compliance Risks

DSTs operate under installment sale provisions from IRC Section 453 but lack explicit IRS recognition. This creates a level of compliance risk. If the structure isn’t properly executed, it could lead to immediate tax liabilities and penalties, undermining the trust’s intended benefits ^[2].

Limited Liquidity

Another downside is restricted access to the full proceeds of a sale. Since DSTs distribute funds through installment payments, liquidity can be limited, which might pose challenges if funds are needed for new investments, debt repayment, or personal expenses.

Investment Risks

The performance of a DST depends heavily on how the trustee manages the investments. There’s no guarantee of positive returns, and poor investment decisions could reduce the value of your deferred proceeds.

Side-by-Side Comparison of DST Pros and Cons

DSTs are ideal for individuals with significant capital gains who can manage deferred payments and handle the associated costs. However, for those needing immediate access to funds or dealing with smaller transactions, the complexities and expenses might outweigh the advantages.

sbb-itb-e766981

When DSTs Work Best and Getting Professional Help

Deferred Sales Trusts (DSTs) shine in situations where traditional tax deferral strategies fall short. They’re particularly useful for growth-stage companies planning a major exit. Imagine a tech startup or scaling business on the verge of a multimillion-dollar sale - capital gains taxes can be a massive financial hit. A DST offers a way to defer those taxes while providing structured payments that align with the founders’ or investors’ long-term financial goals.

DSTs aren’t limited to real estate transactions. They’re also effective for high-value asset sales like businesses, stocks, bonds, or intellectual property. This flexibility allows sellers to diversify their investments beyond real estate.

Another scenario where DSTs prove their worth is when the strict deadlines of a 1031 exchange - like the 45-day identification and 180-day completion rules - can’t be met. In such cases, DSTs can step in to salvage the transaction while still deferring taxes. Real estate investors often rely on this strategy when they can’t find suitable replacement properties within the required timeframe.

DSTs also have estate planning benefits. They allow you to transfer wealth over time while keeping assets out of the taxable estate. However, achieving these benefits requires careful planning and professional oversight.

The Critical Need for Professional Guidance

Because DSTs operate in a complex regulatory environment, professional guidance is non-negotiable. They’re not explicitly recognized by the IRS but instead rely on installment sale provisions under IRC Section 453. Missteps in structuring a DST can lead to immediate tax liabilities, penalties, and interest charges - completely defeating their purpose.

Setting up a DST requires a team of specialists. Tax attorneys ensure compliance with IRS rules, financial advisors design the investment strategy and payment terms, and trustees manage the trust’s assets and reporting. This ongoing coordination demands continuous professional attention.

Phoenix Strategy Group (PSG) specializes in navigating these complexities for growth-stage companies preparing for exits. Their M&A advisory services cover everything from deal structuring to due diligence, ensuring DSTs are set up properly and comply with legal requirements. With experience in over 100 M&A transactions and a track record of building and selling companies worth hundreds of millions, PSG understands the intricate financial planning that DSTs require.

"PSG and David Metzler structured an extraordinary M&A deal during a very chaotic period in our business, and I couldn't be more pleased with our partnership." - Lauren Nagel, CEO, SpokenLayer

PSG’s fractional CFO services provide the strategic financial planning needed to manage DSTs effectively over time. They also offer bookkeeping and accounting services that handle tax preparation and GAAP compliance, ensuring adherence to the strict regulatory requirements DSTs entail.

"As our fractional CFO, they accomplished more in six months than our last two full-time CFOs combined. If you're looking for unparalleled financial strategy and integration, hiring PSG is one of the best decisions you can make." - David Darmstandler, Co-CEO, DataPath

Evaluating DST Suitability

To determine if a DST is the right fit, companies need to model payment scenarios and assess liquidity needs. DSTs are best suited for transactions with significant capital gains that justify the setup costs, which typically range from $5,000 to $25,000 upfront, plus annual fees of 0.5% to 1.5% of the trust’s assets.

Growth-stage companies should consider DSTs if they’re facing large capital gains, looking to diversify beyond their current business or asset class, and have a management team ready to handle deferred payment structures. The ability to customize payment terms makes DSTs appealing for founders who want to align distributions with long-term financial goals or new investment opportunities.

It’s important to note, however, that DSTs come with investment risks. Returns depend on how the trustee manages the trust’s assets. Companies must thoroughly vet trustees and investment managers to ensure they have specific experience with DST structures and a deep understanding of compliance requirements. This due diligence is key to making the most of what DSTs have to offer.

Conclusion

Deferred Sales Trusts (DSTs) present a sophisticated option for deferring capital gains taxes. Their key benefits include postponing tax liabilities, offering adaptable payment structures, and enabling diversification across different investments. This makes them especially appealing for high-value transactions involving businesses, real estate, stocks, or other appreciated assets^[1][2][3]. Unlike some traditional methods, DSTs provide flexibility across a variety of asset types.

That said, there are notable downsides to consider. DSTs come with steep upfront and ongoing maintenance fees, and they operate under the regulatory framework of installment sale provisions (IRC Section 453), which can bring audit and compliance risks^[1][2][3][4]. Additionally, liquidity limitations and the reliance on trustee-managed investments add layers of complexity and potential risk^[1][3].

Given these challenges, professional expertise is not just recommended - it’s essential. Missteps in structuring or compliance could erode the intended tax benefits entirely^[2][5]. Working with seasoned tax attorneys, financial advisors, and trustees is critical to navigating the intricate rules and ensuring proper management. Firms like Phoenix Strategy Group, known for their experience in exit planning and financial strategy, can offer tailored advice to determine if a DST aligns with your financial goals.

While DSTs can be a valuable tool in managing capital gains from an exit, they’re not a one-size-fits-all solution. Weigh the potential tax savings against the associated costs and risks. Consider your liquidity requirements, risk tolerance, and long-term plans. With the right guidance and a well-thought-out strategy, a DST could play a meaningful role in your overall tax planning.

FAQs

What is the difference between Deferred Sales Trusts and 1031 exchanges, and how do I decide which is right for me?

Deferred Sales Trusts and 1031 exchanges are both tax-deferral strategies, but they cater to different needs and offer distinct advantages. A 1031 exchange is tailored for real estate investors aiming to defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting the proceeds exclusively into a similar type of property. On the other hand, a Deferred Sales Trust provides broader flexibility, enabling tax deferral on the sale of various assets - not just real estate - while giving you more control over how and when to reinvest the proceeds.

The right choice depends on your financial objectives and the asset you're selling. If your focus is solely on real estate and you plan to reinvest in another property, a 1031 exchange might suit you best. But if you're dealing with other types of assets or prefer greater control over reinvestment options, a Deferred Sales Trust could be the better option. Speaking with a financial advisor, such as Phoenix Strategy Group, can help you navigate these options and determine the best fit for your specific circumstances.

What are the potential IRS compliance risks with Deferred Sales Trusts, and how can they be managed?

Deferred Sales Trusts (DSTs) can provide appealing tax deferral opportunities, but they aren’t without risks - particularly when it comes to IRS compliance. Missteps such as improper structuring or failing to follow strict IRS guidelines could lead to penalties or even the loss of those tax deferral advantages.

To minimize these risks, it’s crucial to collaborate with seasoned professionals who know the ins and outs of DSTs. Ensuring proper documentation, strictly adhering to IRS regulations, and conducting regular audits are key steps to staying compliant. Trusted advisors, like the team at Phoenix Strategy Group, bring the expertise needed to navigate these challenges with confidence.

Are Deferred Sales Trusts only for high-value asset sales, or can they also work for smaller transactions?

Deferred Sales Trusts (DSTs) are typically linked to large-scale transactions due to the considerable costs involved in setting them up and maintaining them. For smaller deals, these costs might outweigh the potential benefits, making DSTs a better fit for high-value asset sales - think real estate or business interests worth several hundred thousand dollars or more.

That said, whether a DST is the right choice really comes down to your personal financial goals and tax deferral needs. If you're unsure about its suitability for your situation, reaching out to a financial advisor or a specialized service provider, such as Phoenix Strategy Group, can help you navigate the decision-making process and find a solution tailored to your needs.

Related Blog Posts

• Tax Rules for Deferred Purchase Price Payments
• Deferred Sales Trusts vs. 1031 Exchanges
• Deferred Sales Trusts vs. Other Tax Deferral Options
• 1031 Exchange vs. Other Tax-Deferred Strategies