FP&A Strategies for Commodity Price Volatility

Q: How can AI-powered tools help FP&A teams manage commodity price volatility more effectively?

AI-powered tools are transforming how FP&A teams tackle the complexities of volatile commodity markets. By automating tedious tasks like data entry and financial reporting, these tools give teams more time to concentrate on big-picture strategies and critical decision-making. One of AI's standout features is its ability to process massive amounts of market data in real time. This capability provides insights that help predict price swings and fine-tune strategies. On top of that, AI-driven models can simulate various market scenarios, enabling teams to evaluate risks and uncover opportunities with sharper accuracy. This combination of speed and insight equips teams to make smarter financial decisions, even in unpredictable markets.

Managing commodity price swings is a priority for businesses today. Here's how financial planning and analysis (FP&A) teams can tackle this challenge:

Understand the Causes: Geopolitical tensions, supply chain disruptions, climate events, financial speculation, and renewable energy demand all drive price volatility.
Key FP&A Tactics:
- Dynamic cash flow updates to maintain liquidity.
- Rolling forecasts and scenario planning to anticipate changes.
- Hedging strategies to stabilize costs.
- Supply chain diversification to reduce risks.
- Cost pass-through mechanisms to adjust pricing efficiently.
Leverage Technology: AI-powered tools and integrated platforms enhance forecasting accuracy and streamline operations.
Real-World Examples: Companies in agriculture, energy, and construction successfully apply these strategies to manage risks and maintain profitability.

These approaches help businesses stay resilient and seize opportunities in unpredictable markets.

Building a Dynamic Forecasting Framework

The traditional approach of annual budgets struggles to keep up with the fast-paced, unpredictable nature of today’s commodity markets. In contrast, dynamic forecasting adjusts in real time, enabling businesses to respond swiftly to fluctuations in commodity prices. This flexibility is no longer optional - it’s critical for staying competitive. Companies relying on outdated annual budgets risk being caught off guard by sudden cost spikes or supply chain disruptions. On the other hand, businesses that adopt dynamic forecasting can adjust pricing, inventory, and capital allocation strategies in step with market changes.

Setting Up Rolling Forecasts

Rolling forecasts are a cornerstone of dynamic financial planning, offering continuous insights into future performance rather than sticking to static, once-a-year projections. These forecasts focus on key operational drivers like raw material costs, supplier lead times, and inventory turnover rates, ensuring financial plans stay relevant.

Interestingly, an EPM Channel survey revealed that only 42% of organizations use rolling forecasts. Even more striking, about 20% of companies that tried this approach eventually abandoned it, often due to challenges in implementation.

A step-by-step rollout tends to work best. Starting with a single department or unit that has clear exposure to commodity risks allows teams to fine-tune their methods before scaling up. In volatile markets, increasing the frequency of updates - moving from quarterly to monthly or even weekly - helps companies stay aligned with current conditions. The forecast horizon should also reflect the nature of the business. For industries with significant volatility, a 12-month horizon with frequent updates might be ideal. In more stable sectors, planning further ahead may make sense.

Once rolling forecasts are in place, scenario planning can take financial preparation to the next level.

Scenario Planning and Stress Testing

Scenario planning shifts forecasting from a one-dimensional prediction to a powerful risk management tool. Instead of relying on a single projection, businesses create multiple scenarios - such as best case, worst case, and most likely outcomes - to model various market conditions. For instance, if a key commodity historically fluctuates by 40% annually, forecasts should account for similar swings.

Stress testing builds on this concept by examining how financial plans hold up under extreme conditions. Think of scenarios like a sharp rise in raw material costs paired with a significant drop in demand due to an economic downturn. The real benefit of this planning lies in actionable strategies. By setting clear trigger points - like when commodity prices hit a specific threshold - companies can respond promptly, whether that means renegotiating supplier contracts or adjusting prices temporarily.

To stay effective, these scenarios need regular updates, often on a monthly basis, to reflect evolving market realities.

Using Real-Time Data Integration

Real-time data integration transforms forecasting from a periodic task into a seamless, ongoing process. Modern financial planning tools can automatically pull data - such as commodity prices, supplier quotes, and operational metrics - into forecasting models, cutting down on manual work and reducing delays.

Advanced platforms now integrate data from ERP systems (tracking inventory, purchase orders, and production schedules) and CRM systems (providing sales pipeline and demand forecasts). Artificial intelligence takes this a step further by analyzing data from multiple sources to uncover patterns that might otherwise go unnoticed. Research indicates that organizations using AI for forecasting report 20% or fewer errors in half of cases, with 25% of enterprises achieving at least a 50% reduction in errors.

The key to success lies in choosing software that works seamlessly with existing systems. Companies like Phoenix Strategy Group specialize in helping businesses implement these integrated frameworks, enabling them to leverage advanced technology and real-time data for more accurate and responsive planning.

To avoid overwhelming complexity, it’s wise to start small - focusing on the minimum data needed to grasp performance drivers. Over time, as confidence grows, integration can be expanded. This gradual approach ensures that technology enhances, rather than complicates, the forecasting process.

Risk Mitigation Strategies for Commodity Price Volatility

Predicting price movements with dynamic forecasting is helpful, but a well-rounded approach that combines multiple strategies often yields better results. By doing so, businesses can achieve steadier margins and improve cash flow predictability.

Let’s delve into three key strategies: hedging techniques, supply chain diversification, and cost pass-through mechanisms.

Hedging Strategies and Financial Instruments

Hedging helps transform uncertain commodity costs into more predictable expenses. The right financial instruments, when structured effectively, can make this process smoother. One popular approach is the use of commodity collars, which combine buying and selling options to manage price risks. For example:

For producers: A natural gas producer might use a costless collar with a $4.50 ceiling (call option) and a $3.50 floor (put option). This setup protects against prices dropping below $3.50 but caps the upside at $4.50. If prices stay within this range, the producer benefits from market rates.
For consumers: The same collar works in reverse, shielding against prices rising above $4.50 while limiting gains if prices fall below $3.50.

To make collar strategies effective, companies must assess the "moneyness" of options - how the strike price compares to the current market price. Accurate pricing models are crucial, as is ensuring that settlements align with physical exposures. Additionally, having sufficient credit lines and robust internal controls helps prevent unauthorized transactions.

For those seeking more flexibility, dynamic collars adjust as prices shift, potentially increasing hedge positions over time. However, this approach requires advanced risk management systems and clear financial objectives to manage the added complexity.

Building Diversified Supplier Networks

Shifting focus from financial markets to operational strategies, supply chain diversification is another way to manage risk. A 2023 survey found that 97% of companies are rethinking their supply chains. Geographic diversification, for instance, can reduce exposure to regional disruptions and price swings. According to Gartner, 57% of industrial manufacturers with operations in China are exploring a "supplier + 1" strategy to mitigate risks.

"When making a decision, first determine what you are trying to protect - a product line, government contract or market access... And then consider what you're trying to protect against: sole-sourcing risks, increasing labor costs, tariffs, lead times or regulatory burdens", advises Kamala Raman, Senior Director Analyst at Gartner.

Nearshoring is also gaining traction. Since the USMCA agreement in 2020, foreign direct investment into North America has surged by 134%, reaching approximately $219 billion. For industries like automotive and electronics manufacturing, Mexico offers a compelling alternative to China due to favorable costs and trade policies.

When diversifying suppliers, businesses should evaluate potential partners based on their financial stability, production capacity, quality standards, and ethical practices. Multi-sourcing - working with three or more suppliers - can further enhance resilience, foster competition, and potentially lead to better pricing. However, managing these relationships can be more complex.

These operational adjustments work hand-in-hand with forecasting methods to build a stronger, more adaptable supply chain.

Cost Pass-Through Mechanisms

Cost pass-through mechanisms allow businesses to adjust pricing automatically in response to commodity price changes, safeguarding margins without constant renegotiations. Success here depends on clear contractual agreements that outline terms, conditions, and procedures for price adjustments. These frameworks ensure costs are tied directly to specific projects or services without any hidden markups.

Dynamic pricing models, supported by modern accounting software, enable real-time tracking and adjustments. Automated tools can simplify the process, ensuring accuracy in pricing updates.

Implementing cost pass-through mechanisms requires tight coordination across finance, procurement, and operations teams. Regular reviews of pricing frameworks and risk protocols help keep strategies aligned with changing market conditions. Conducting a Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) analysis ensures all direct and indirect costs are accounted for.

"A good pricing model enables the parties to adjust underlying pricing assumptions as objectives, costs and shifts in consumption, changes the value being exchanged between the parties", explains Jeanette Nyden, Owner of Nyden on Negotiation.

These strategies lay a solid foundation for leveraging advanced technologies to manage price volatility more effectively. For tailored guidance, consider consulting the experts at Phoenix Strategy Group (https://phoenixstrategy.group).

Technology and Tools for Managing Volatility

Today's technology equips FP&A teams to move beyond reactive strategies, enabling a more proactive approach to navigating commodity price fluctuations.

AI-Powered Forecasting and Analysis

FP&A teams are increasingly turning to artificial intelligence to enhance forecasting capabilities. AI simplifies the complex task of commodity forecasting by analyzing vast datasets that traditional methods struggle to handle. It evaluates historical prices, weather trends, news sentiment, and economic indicators to uncover patterns that might otherwise remain hidden.

According to Gartner, 58% of finance functions were already leveraging AI in 2024, with projections suggesting that number will climb to 90% by 2026. For example, a global industrial goods manufacturer saw a 50% improvement in forecasting accuracy after implementing an AI-driven system to predict demand and revenue.

Roland Berger’s AI-based CostIQ approach highlights the practical benefits of such technology. Pieter Niehues, Partner at Roland Berger, explains:

"With our AI-based CostIQ approach, we continuously help companies identify significant opportunities for cost and risk reduction and optimize purchasing decisions considering market developments. This enables our clients to save up to 5% of raw material procurement costs even in a volatile market environment."

AI also excels in real-time monitoring, allowing businesses to respond quickly to commodity price changes. By automating tasks like data entry, trade confirmations, and compliance reporting, these systems free up analysts to focus on strategic initiatives. Gartner predicts that by 2027, 90% of descriptive and diagnostic analytics in finance will be entirely automated.

Another strength of AI lies in scenario planning. It models the potential effects of different economic and regulatory changes while identifying unusual patterns in financial data to generate scenario-based forecasts.

Integrated Financial Platforms

In addition to AI, integrated financial platforms are transforming FP&A operations. These platforms consolidate financial and operational data into a single system, eliminating the inefficiencies of juggling multiple spreadsheets and disconnected tools.

FP&A teams often spend up to 75% of their time collecting data, leaving little room for analysis. This inefficiency costs U.S. companies $7.8 billion annually. Modern platforms address this by enabling real-time collaboration and offering advanced tools like driver-based planning and scenario modeling. Rolling forecasts, which can be updated weekly or monthly, are particularly valuable during periods of volatility. Companies using agile FP&A methods report an 80% reduction in planning time and a 95% improvement in forecasting accuracy.

AI tools within these platforms enhance data mapping and anomaly detection, reducing errors significantly. Generative AI features further streamline operations by analyzing contracts and CRM data to spot discrepancies that could affect commodity agreements.

Jon Laudie, CFO of Zerorez, underscores the importance of integration in FP&A:

"I think great FP&A in my mind is a function that is deeply integrated into the strategic planning and the decision-making of any organization."

A key tactic is separating budgeting from forecasting, allowing for real-time adjustments based on current market conditions. By incorporating data from sales, supply chain, and operations directly into financial plans, teams can respond more effectively to changing circumstances.

Blockchain for Smart Contracts

Blockchain technology complements these platforms by automating contract management and enhancing transparency. With blockchain, smart contracts execute predefined actions - like trades, pricing adjustments, or payments - when specific conditions are met, reducing delays and minimizing risks.

The blockchain supply chain management market is expected to reach $17.15 billion by 2030, driven by its ability to create secure, unchangeable transaction records. For instance, smart contracts can automate commodity transactions, ensuring smoother operations even in volatile markets.

Blockchain also reduces administrative overhead. In container transport, paperwork can account for up to 50% of costs, but blockchain automates documentation and verification, cutting down this burden. In agriculture, AgriDigital made history by completing the first blockchain-based grain sale settlement, increasing trust and traceability in the supply chain. Similarly, IBM Food Trust uses blockchain to provide real-time tracking of food origin, quality, and safety.

For FP&A teams, blockchain improves supply chain visibility, enhancing forecasting accuracy by flagging potential disruptions early. It also ensures all parties in a contract have access to the same real-time data, simplifying contract management.

Oliver Knapp, Senior Partner at Roland Berger, emphasizes the value of data-driven strategies:

"Especially in times of rapid change and market volatility, it's imperative for companies to utilize Big Data analytics as their 'compass' in raw material procurement. This is the only way they can navigate the storms of price risk and maintain their profit margins."

To get started, companies should pilot blockchain projects focused on specific goals like improving traceability or reducing fraud. This approach helps assess the technology’s benefits and technical requirements before full-scale implementation.

Together, these technologies strengthen FP&A strategies, helping businesses manage commodity volatility without complicating financial operations. For organizations ready to take the next step, Phoenix Strategy Group (https://phoenixstrategy.group) provides tailored FP&A systems and data engineering services to keep pace in unpredictable markets.

sbb-itb-e766981

Case Studies in Commodity Price Management

The following examples highlight how companies apply FP&A strategies to navigate the ups and downs of commodity prices effectively.

Agricultural Products Company

Agricultural businesses often encounter unique challenges when entering markets, particularly due to unpredictable commodity price movements. To tackle these fluctuations, many companies adopt a mix of strategies. These include financial hedging through tools like forwards, futures, swaps, and options; supplier diversification by working with multiple vendors under fixed-price agreements or price caps; and adjusting product designs to rely less on volatile raw materials.

Procurement teams play a pivotal role in these efforts. They focus on conducting in-depth market analyses, benchmarking prices regularly, accessing real-time data, and negotiating contracts with protective clauses. Tools like rolling forecasts and real-time dashboards provide agility, enabling these businesses to respond swiftly to market shifts. This combination of strategies helps ensure cost predictability, especially during phases of market expansion.

Energy Sector: EV Battery Manufacturing

Umicore, a Belgium-based producer of cathode active materials for lithium-ion batteries, offers a strong example of managing the volatility of metal prices in the energy sector. In July 2024, the company implemented a comprehensive strategy tailored to the diverse challenges posed by various battery metal markets.

Tom Meulemans, the business head of cobalt & precursors at Umicore, highlighted their approach:

"At Umicore we have very strict policies to mitigate our exposure to metal price volatility. We apply a multi-strategy approach combining various hedging tools to manage metal price fluctuations more effectively, ensuring greater financial stability and predictability."

For nickel, Umicore uses financially settled futures contracts in the paper market to shield against sudden price changes. In less developed markets like cobalt and lithium, the company carefully manages inventory levels, aligning them with both market trends and customer demand. Additionally, customer contracts include pricing mechanisms that adjust sales prices based on raw material costs, effectively sharing some of the price risk. This strategy demonstrates the importance of flexibility in hedging and inventory management when dealing with volatile markets.

Construction Materials Business

For companies in the construction materials sector, commodity price fluctuations pose significant challenges since materials often account for a large portion of project budgets. To maintain financial control, these businesses rely on a mix of technology and disciplined management.

Top-performing firms use project management software to gain real-time insights into project finances, ensuring accurate budgeting and cost control across various projects. Financial tracking tools simplify expense reporting, while advanced forecasting techniques - blending historical data with predictive models - improve cost predictability. Cloud-based ERP systems tie these tools together, automating repetitive tasks and delivering timely financial data. This integration of technology allows businesses to adapt quickly to price changes while keeping project costs under tight control.

Key Takeaway

These examples show that managing commodity price volatility requires strategies tailored to each industry’s specific needs, market conditions, and available financial tools. A recurring theme is the use of real-time monitoring technology combined with robust risk management practices to stay ahead of market changes.

Key Takeaways for Managing Commodity Price Volatility

Managing commodity price volatility requires a combination of financial discipline, operational adaptability, and smart use of technology. Here's a closer look at some key strategies for navigating these challenges effectively.

Hedging plays a critical role in managing price swings. By using financial instruments, businesses can gain the predictability needed for accurate budgeting and planning. It's worth noting that hedging is designed to reduce risk and provide stability - not to generate profits through speculative market moves.

Regularly updated rolling forecasts are another essential tool. These allow financial planning and analysis (FP&A) teams to stay in sync with shifting market conditions, enabling quicker responses to price fluctuations.

Diversifying the supply chain helps cushion the impact of price shocks. By working with multiple suppliers and securing fixed-price agreements, businesses can balance cost considerations with risk management.

Collaboration across departments - procurement, finance, and treasury - is equally important. Procurement teams can offer early insights into market trends, while finance teams assess cash flow impacts. Together, these groups can make swift, well-informed decisions.

Technology integration amplifies the effectiveness of these strategies. Real-time data and AI-powered tools can detect trends early, preventing issues from spiraling. Companies using integrated financial platforms often handle commodity price volatility more effectively than those relying on outdated manual processes.

Successful mid-market businesses approach commodity price volatility as a constant operational challenge rather than a rare crisis. They prioritize building flexible cost structures, maintaining sufficient cash reserves, and routinely stress-testing their exposure to volatile sectors. This proactive approach supports steady growth, even in unpredictable markets.

For businesses entering new markets, adopting these strategies becomes even more critical. Establishing strong volatility management practices early on ensures financial stability, allowing companies to seize growth opportunities while minimizing risks.

Finally, consider tapping into specialized advisory services, like those offered by Phoenix Strategy Group, to implement these strategies effectively and tailor them to your unique needs.

FAQs

What are the best ways to use rolling forecasts to handle commodity price volatility?

To manage commodity price volatility with rolling forecasts, businesses should prioritize a few essential strategies. Begin by using advanced forecasting tools that can handle real-time data. These tools allow your forecasts to remain current, reflecting the latest market trends and enabling quicker, more informed decisions.

Engage stakeholders from various departments to bring in diverse viewpoints and ensure forecasts align with overall business objectives. Make it a point to update your forecasts regularly - monthly or quarterly works best - to account for new data and shifting trends. This consistent approach enhances accuracy and allows your business to respond to market fluctuations more effectively.

How can AI-powered tools help FP&A teams manage commodity price volatility more effectively?

AI-powered tools are transforming how FP&A teams tackle the complexities of volatile commodity markets. By automating tedious tasks like data entry and financial reporting, these tools give teams more time to concentrate on big-picture strategies and critical decision-making.

One of AI's standout features is its ability to process massive amounts of market data in real time. This capability provides insights that help predict price swings and fine-tune strategies. On top of that, AI-driven models can simulate various market scenarios, enabling teams to evaluate risks and uncover opportunities with sharper accuracy. This combination of speed and insight equips teams to make smarter financial decisions, even in unpredictable markets.

How can diversifying your supply chain help manage commodity price volatility?

Diversifying your supply chain is a smart way to tackle the risks that come with fluctuating commodity prices. By sourcing materials from multiple suppliers in different regions, businesses can avoid over-reliance on a single provider. This approach helps cushion the blow from localized disruptions like natural disasters, political upheavals, or trade restrictions.

Beyond mitigating risks, a diversified supply chain adds flexibility, making it easier to adjust to shifting market conditions. It also opens the door to negotiating more favorable contracts, keeping inventory levels in check, and easing the financial burden of sudden price surges. By actively managing their supply chains, businesses can better handle the ups and downs of volatile markets and stay steady even in uncertain times.